Monday, December 04, 2006

Zelda (Minish Cap), not quite perfect

In anticipation of my Wii coming on Wed night/Thur morning, I've been playing Zelda: The Minish Cap on my DS. I bought at least a year ago, but an early classic Zelda 'tricky bit' stymied progress and I shelved it until the overwheming Zness of the Wii launch got me back in the mood.

I won't go on about Zelda for people who don't know; suffice to say that the Z games are works of art, with attention to detail and imagination you won't find almost anywhere else.

At the weekend I contributed my opinion to gaming industry site Gamasutra's 'question of the week', on the subject of game length. Here it is (at bottom of page). I'd rather games were short, and cheaper. If I could play and finish a game in a few hours, I'd be happy, assuming the game was good. I don't have 50 hours to play a game any more, so I feel aggrieved at having to pay for 50 hours of content. More fundamentally, as some people pointed out, if I play for 10 hours I want 10 hours of content; but many games have 10 hours of content repeated, padded, and dragged out to 30, 40, 50 hours. For me that's a waste of time. Give me 5 interesting and varied hours.

This morning I was on what I thought was the last section of my Zelda game, and the battery gave out, and I lost about 15 minutes' progress, and I had one of those moments when I wondered whether I could be bothered to replay them. I consulted the walkthrough I've been using to keep my momentum up (I have no qualms about using them - why waste a valuable hour of frustration on a puzzle I can't solve in ten minutes?) and discovered I was a long and difficulty-packed way from the end, so I decided to call it a day. I once read, if you're not enjoying reading a book, stop reading it; there are plenty of good books around, so why waste your time on a boring one? Same applies exactly.

Z games aren't boring - in the science of game design they're the Principia, the pinnacle of the form - but this one goes on a bit. I've heard the Wii Zelda game trumpeted as 70 hours long. Well, I'll make an exception, just, but I would rather they extracted the best 25 hours. I can't see how that would be any less good.

No comments: